The Poppy War by R.F. Kuang | Book Review
Sunday, 9 August 2020 • book review, books, fantasy
Any
fans of the fantasy genre know there are certain books that are must
reads for any fan. You don’t have to like them, but they’re still
considered quintessential. Lord of the Rings, Harry Potter,
The Wheel of Time, Mistborn, Pern, The
Inheritance Trilogy, and more are easy suggestions for anyone
wanting to get into the genre. When a new quintessential fantasy book
comes out it makes big enough waves that it’s hard to ignore. The
Poppy War by R F Kuang was one of those books. It was published
in 2018 and I finally got around to reading it, what did I think?
Here’s my review.
As
always, let’s start with the premise in my own words. Rin is a war
orphan raised in a podunk little village in the Nikara Empire. She
wants nothing more than to escape the opium dealers that raised her
and the only way is to ace the Keju, a nationwide test that, if aced,
would allow her into the prestigious Sinegard military academy. She
does so but finds that being a dark skinned girl from a poor village
marks her as easy prey for bullies. Rin catches the eye of the
reclusive Lore teacher and learns that she has the potential to wield
the powers of a shaman. But with war threatening to break out with
the neighboring country of Mugen, everything she has and hasn’t
learned, may be put to the test.
Before
you pick up this book you should know a couple things. The first is
that this is labeled as a “grimdark” fantasy. That means that…
well… things are grim and dark. And boy do things get dark. I don’t
generally believe in trigger warnings but I’m going to make an
exception for this book because at one point, things got so dark that
I just felt wrong. I felt like I had to take a shower. So consider
this your trigger warning for rape, torture, murder, and violence in
general. Just think of stuff that would make Jigsaw shudder and
you'll have an idea of the kind of shit that happens at a few points
in this book. See? Grimdark.
Kuang
borrows heavily from history and it shows. But what also shows is her
imagination and talent as a writer. While Kuang does borrow her
world’s back story from the Sino-Japanese war (during WWII) with
added touches from the Opium Wars and China’s Song Dynasty, she
does make them her own. With books like this, an author can borrow
all they want but it won’t make the story interesting. Lucky for
the reader, Kuang does make it interesting. The world is rich and
though it’s based on ancient China, it becomes its own creature. In
the beginning some of the characters easily fell into tropes but
later blossomed into something more.
A
lot of people raved about this book and while there is plenty to rave
over, there’s also plenty to be critical about. The most pressing
issues is the pacing of the book. The first half of the story was
slowly paced and after the war broke out it ramped up and while one
could argue that it was honest in terms of the tides of war, as a
reader it comes across as a little jarring. Also, the first half of
the book felt a little like a Harry Potter
fanfiction with Rin as Harry, Nezha as Malfoy, Kitay as Ron, Jun as
Snape, and Jiang as Dumbledore.
Another
low point of the book was Rin's outstanding stupidity. Before anyone
says anything. I get it. She's a kid, she basically had to raise
herself, and none of her masters can answer a question with a
straight answer to save their lives, but all the dumb decisions she
made got old. Even though I did really like this book, her final bad
decision just made me shake my head and realize that I sorely missed
my favorite character who died half a book ago.
I
want to finish up on a high note but one more thing that bothered me
was the overly violent things that happened. They only happened a
couple times and I do get it, war is horrible, but come on. I didn't
need some of the graphic and bloody descriptions. I'm already on
Nikara's side. I don't need to hear about all the crimes against
humanity Mugen committed too.
So
like I said, let's try to end this on a happy note. I did like this
book. It's not a modern masterpiece as some fans of the book would
have you believe. But it's a solid and enjoyable novel that brings
an interesting new world and magic system into our lives. While the
ending didn't put me off reading the sequel, it did push the sequel
farther down my TBR than it originally was. I have no need to pick it
up right away, but some time this year I'll read it.
The
Poppy War by R.F. Kuang
gets a 7 out of 11
Fatale | Comic Review
Sunday, 2 August 2020
This
year my reading goal is bigger than ever. I aim to read 125 book, but
seeing as last year I barely made it over my goal of 60, you may be
wondering, “is that a good idea?” To which I say, it is if I’m
counting manga and graphic novels. My wife and I have a rule in our
house. If it counts on Goodreads, it counts as a book, so I jumped at
my higher than normal goal with gusto.
The
first comic series I read was Paper Girls by Brian K Vaughan and
after that I wanted to finally finish the Fables series by Bill
Willingham but before I did that I picked up Fatale
by written by Ed Brubacker with artist Sean Philips. It was a short comic series from
way back in 2012 that I collected as it came out, but stopped reading
it even though I was still buying the issues. What did I think, eight
years later? Here’s my review.
I
was 29 back in 2012 and while that’s technically well into
adulthood, I know now that I wasn’t quite as mature as I should
have been. One sign of that was how impressed with myself I was that
I was buying a mature rated comic that wasn’t pornographic. See?
Mature! Don’t get me wrong, this isn’t a comic for kids. There’s
murder, nudity, sex, ritualistic sacrifice, and plenty of blood. So
consider that your content warning.
Fatale
revolves around Josephine, a mysterious woman who seems to draw the
attention of men like moths to a raging bonfire. She has power over
men. They not only notice her, but she can get them to do whatever
she wants. She lives on the run from a mysterious adversary who wants
nothing more than to sacrifice her to long forgotten gods for an
unclear purpose. Josephine meats Nick who falls under her spell and
is now caught up in everything.
We
might as well call Nick “Whitey McGee” because he’s just one of
many white male characters with no personality that serve no real purpose other than to
lust over Jo and to be used as her tools, even when they think
they’re being chivalrous and protecting her. There’s only two
male characters who don’t feel like useless plebeians. One of them
is only in one short part of the story, a Native American man who was
connected to a “Fatale” before Jo, and the man who saved Jo for
the very first time.
So
basically, even though Jo is the main character and has power over
men, her story is still told via the men she encounters. In fact, it
feels like her story is some sort of reverse “woman in a
refrigerator,” and instead of this reverse trope feeling like it’s
a step forward for women in fiction, it serves as more of a lethargic
step back.
Look,
not every piece of fiction has to be some super woke work of art or
some diverse rainbow. But especially in today’s cultural climate,
the lack of characters of color (except for the lone Native American)
and Bechdel test passing women stands out.
What’s
worse than the lack of inclusivity is the fact that the story is so
bland. Each particular volume is entertaining enough to be a tad
enjoyable, but the story as a whole is more convoluted and fragmented
more than humpty dumpty after an earthquake. Brubaker spends too much
time diving into Jo’s backstory and the story of the Fatales as a
whole. So much so that the main story gets lost in the process. The
entire third volume takes place in the past and focuses on the advent
of Josephine and a few Fatales who came before her. But even though
we get this volume that focuses on her beginnings, it’s still never
made clear how or why she got her powers. I realize that leaving a
mystery unsolved or not answering every single question can be an
important and effective narrative device, but in this case it left me
cold and wanting more.
If
I took each volume and critiqued it by itself, they’d get a higher
average score than the story as a whole. But I have to rate this as
one story. In the end, Fatale is a good idea that shows a lot of
promise but it misses the mark so bad that I wonder what Brubaker and
Phillips were aiming for in the first place. This could have been a
great series but the sloppy narrative and poor characters keep it
from being all it could have been.
Fatale by Ed Brubacker gets a 4 out of 11
Reading Rush 2020 TBR
Friday, 17 July 2020 • books, Readathon, TBR, To Be Read, ya books
My wife and I love readathons. We also like finding readathons that repeat each year and make them part of our yearly book rituals. The Reading Rush was a readathon we did before and enjoyed it so we figured, why not do it again? The only issue is that she's the reading equivalent of The Flash and I'm a normal human with a limp. The Reading Rush has seven prompts so the ideal goal is to read seven books, in one week. So in this TBR you'll find a lot of super short books and graphic novels but also some longer books that I'll read if I can. So here I am, back again, with my TBR.
Read a book with a cover that matches the color of your birth stone.
Want to know a terrible secret? I once was a huge comic nerd and am currently trying to get back into it. I love Superman. He's my favorite hero. I think Henry Cavill is the best thing to happen to Superman since the first film. But I still have never read Superman: Red Son. I know the story, the bare bones of it. But I've never actually read the whole thing. So since this cover is red, and my birth stone is the Ruby, I figured I'd read this for the readathon.
Superman: Red Son is a "what if" story asking the question "What would have happened if Superman's pod had landed in the USSR instead of Kansas. What if he was raised by communist Russia instead of the Kents?
Read a book that starts with the word "The."
I've recently been trying to read more books by people of color and the LGBTQ community. I say that, but the first two books on my TBR for this readathon are by white men. In my defense, the reason is because the books I have on my main TBR by POCs and the LGBTQ community are longer than I think I can conquer in a week.
That being said, I'm picking up The Pearl by John Steinbeck because it's super short and also considered to be a classic. Also, despite the fact that some people dislike him, he was an early advocate for anti-racism. He wasn't perfect by today's woke standards but for his time he was pretty damn good, so why not?
This book is about a poor pearl fisherman and how one day he finds the biggest pearl he's ever seen and how the sudden windfall changes his life, but change isn't always for the better. It's a retelling a of classic Mexican fairy tale.
Read a book that inspired a movie you've already seen.
It was hard to find a short book that had a movie based on it and not visa versa. I have plenty of movie novelizations that I could read in a day, but not the other way around. So I was lucky to find this one. Also it'll be interesting to see how close the great Hayo Miyazaki got to the original source material.
Sophie is an 18 year old woman and is the eldest of 3 sisters. She knows her future is set for her. She's going to take over the family hat shop, which she doesn't want to do. But one day she's cursed by an old crone to look like an old woman. She leaves her house and finds work as a housekeeper for a notorious wizard name Howl. It's there that she finds hope that she could return to normal, but to do so she has to get to know the wizard, help strike a bargain between him and a fire demon, and meet the witch that cursed her head on. Easy, right?
Read the first book you touch.
Here we go! A book co-written by a person of color. Amal El-Mohtar is a Lebanese-Canadian writer of poetry and speculative fiction. This book has also been on my TBR list since earlier this year when we found it at a library book sale. I'm really excited to read this and I'm pretty sure I'll give it five stars.
This book is about two agents involved in a war across time. These two agents, Red and Blue are on opposite sides of the battle but leave messages for each other and gradually fall in love.
Read a book completely outside your house.
This book was put on my radar when I was looking for books to read for an LGBTQ readathon earlier in the year. Sarah Gailey is a non-binary author from San Francisco so that's a double whammy. I get to broaden my reading horizons AND I get to read a local(ish) author.
River of Teeth is set in an alternate United States in Louisiana in the late 1800s. In 1850 President James Buchanan approved the import hippopotamus into the states for the purpose of a new meat source. Decades later, in a lawless Louisiana, the hippos have run wild and a man named Winslow Houndstooth has been hired to help clear them out.
Read a book in a genre that you've always wanted to read more of.
Ariel by Sylvia Plath or The Poet X by Elizabeth Acevedo
![]() |
| Thanks to my wife for this picture. She took it for her own blog and Instagram. |
Ariel is a book of poetry and I don't read much poetry so that should be self explanatory. The Poet X is a YA novel told in verse, which can be counted as poetry as well.
This one is up in the air and it all depends on how many of these books I can knock out in one day. Ariel is on this list just in case I'm falling behind. It's 105 pages of poetry so it'll be a super fast read. The copy I'm going to read isn't the copy feature in the picture above. Turns out, Plath's husband was a huge asshole and edited the book, taking out poems that made him look bad and rearranged them to give the book an overall happy feeling. The newer, non-edited version is on hold at the library and will be the edition I read.
The Poet X by Elizabeth Acevedo is a story told in verse about a young woman from Harlem named Xiomara and how she discovers slam poetry as an outlet for her feelings and as a way to understand her mom's religion. I really want to read this so if I can't get around to it for the readathon, I'll read it just for fun.
Read a book that takes place on a different continent than where you live.
If I only saved Clap When You Land by Elizabeth Acevedo I could have done two books by her for this readathon. Instead I decided on The Bookshop, a book that has been on my TBR since it was made into a movie in 2018. I've owned the book for a while too but never got around to it. So I figured why not?
The Bookshop follows Florence, a woman who moves to a small town in England and opens a bookshop. She finds that the small town isn't fully open to a book store and must deal with a group of locals who want nothing more than for her to fail, but she has an ally in the form of an old recluse.
So there we have it. That's my TBR for The Reading Rush. It's what I hope to read but I'm going to be honest with myself and say that what's on my TBR may not be what I actually end up reading. Maybe I blow through three books in one day and choose a different and longer book for a prompt. Maybe I'll hit a poorly timed reading slump and only do a few books but try my best to double count them. Or maybe, just maybe, I'll stick to my TBR exactly. Only time will tell.
The Bookshop follows Florence, a woman who moves to a small town in England and opens a bookshop. She finds that the small town isn't fully open to a book store and must deal with a group of locals who want nothing more than for her to fail, but she has an ally in the form of an old recluse.
So there we have it. That's my TBR for The Reading Rush. It's what I hope to read but I'm going to be honest with myself and say that what's on my TBR may not be what I actually end up reading. Maybe I blow through three books in one day and choose a different and longer book for a prompt. Maybe I'll hit a poorly timed reading slump and only do a few books but try my best to double count them. Or maybe, just maybe, I'll stick to my TBR exactly. Only time will tell.
Paper Girls by Brian K. Vaughan | Comic Review
Sunday, 12 July 2020
I was already familiar with Brian K Vaughan's work since I had read Y: The Last Man and the first five volumes of Saga. But when my friend Figbar was moving away and was getting rid of some of his stuff, he gave me a bunch of comics and in that stash I found Paper Girls. A 30 issue series that's a quick and very fun read. Here's my review.
I love comics, but it's easy for me to get burnt out. Especially with Marvel and DC. There are just a million crossovers and huge events that mean you have to buy issues from series you never bought before. And if you don't do that, you tend to get lost. Also, there's the constant question of what is currently in cannon and what isn't. That's what I like about publishers like Image, IDW, and Boom (to name a few). They tend to have series that don't go on forever and even if they're long running series, they tend to not have a million crossovers. I know that the 30 issues of Paper Girls is it. As far as I know there isn't a sequel or any spin offs. I still have the entire Final Crisis/ Blackest Night/Brightest Day run with every single issue, but that takes up a whole short box of comics. So instead of diving into that hubbub, why not tackle a short but thoroughly enjoyable series?
Paper Girls is about four 12 year old girls, Erin, Mac, KJ, and Tiffany, who deliver newspapers in a fictional suburb of Cleveland. It's the morning after Halloween 1988 when the town is invaded by a mysterious force from the future and the girls are caught up in it.The series ran from October 2015 to July 2019 and was published by Image Comics.
I got sucked into this series right away. Vaughan created four very different and unique characters that I grew to like and care for as the story went on. These kids were believable. They weren't goody two shoes little girls but they also weren't written like adults. They had a good mix of child and adult qualities which was a very realistic. It was also nice seeing a story about four young females who didn't just sit around and wait for someone to come save them. It was impressive that it was a female centric comic with kids and it was done well. From my male point of reference, Brian K Vaughan writes women well. That is to say, there weren't any glaring problems that stood out to me. My wife is reading this series now and thus far, she has no problems with it. So that's a good sign.
The story got confusing at times but it I always eventually got it. The girls kept getting into trouble the whole time, but it always made sense. The flow of events worked, which isn't always easy to do with a story involving time travel, but Vaughan was able to keep the story moving without it going contrived.
The only issue I really had has to do with the ending so it kind of limits what I can say, as I don't want to spoil the whole thing for you. What I can say with that there were certain aspects of the story that didn't seem to matter at all in the end. There were a few things the girls did that had no effect on the outcome. This could be a good thing. It could show that sometimes things are just out of your control. But to me it just felt like parts (but not all) of the girls' struggle were pointless.
That aside, Paper Girls was good. It was a truly unique story with well written and engaging characters that kept me turning the pages from issue 1 to issue 30. Even though I liked it, I'm still glad it ended because it never got the chance to get stale. If you're interested in a good limited run comic series, this is it.
Paper Girls by Brian K Vaughan gets an 8 out of 11
I love comics, but it's easy for me to get burnt out. Especially with Marvel and DC. There are just a million crossovers and huge events that mean you have to buy issues from series you never bought before. And if you don't do that, you tend to get lost. Also, there's the constant question of what is currently in cannon and what isn't. That's what I like about publishers like Image, IDW, and Boom (to name a few). They tend to have series that don't go on forever and even if they're long running series, they tend to not have a million crossovers. I know that the 30 issues of Paper Girls is it. As far as I know there isn't a sequel or any spin offs. I still have the entire Final Crisis/ Blackest Night/Brightest Day run with every single issue, but that takes up a whole short box of comics. So instead of diving into that hubbub, why not tackle a short but thoroughly enjoyable series?
Paper Girls is about four 12 year old girls, Erin, Mac, KJ, and Tiffany, who deliver newspapers in a fictional suburb of Cleveland. It's the morning after Halloween 1988 when the town is invaded by a mysterious force from the future and the girls are caught up in it.The series ran from October 2015 to July 2019 and was published by Image Comics.
I got sucked into this series right away. Vaughan created four very different and unique characters that I grew to like and care for as the story went on. These kids were believable. They weren't goody two shoes little girls but they also weren't written like adults. They had a good mix of child and adult qualities which was a very realistic. It was also nice seeing a story about four young females who didn't just sit around and wait for someone to come save them. It was impressive that it was a female centric comic with kids and it was done well. From my male point of reference, Brian K Vaughan writes women well. That is to say, there weren't any glaring problems that stood out to me. My wife is reading this series now and thus far, she has no problems with it. So that's a good sign.
The story got confusing at times but it I always eventually got it. The girls kept getting into trouble the whole time, but it always made sense. The flow of events worked, which isn't always easy to do with a story involving time travel, but Vaughan was able to keep the story moving without it going contrived.
The only issue I really had has to do with the ending so it kind of limits what I can say, as I don't want to spoil the whole thing for you. What I can say with that there were certain aspects of the story that didn't seem to matter at all in the end. There were a few things the girls did that had no effect on the outcome. This could be a good thing. It could show that sometimes things are just out of your control. But to me it just felt like parts (but not all) of the girls' struggle were pointless.
That aside, Paper Girls was good. It was a truly unique story with well written and engaging characters that kept me turning the pages from issue 1 to issue 30. Even though I liked it, I'm still glad it ended because it never got the chance to get stale. If you're interested in a good limited run comic series, this is it.
Paper Girls by Brian K Vaughan gets an 8 out of 11
I Messed Up Book Tag
Sunday, 5 July 2020
It's time for another book tag! Yay! This one is the I Messed Up Book Tag and it revolves around things I got wrong or didn't do in regards to books. Enjoy!
1. A character appearance that you misread and imagined differently.
Hester
Shaw from the Mortal Engines
series. In the first book she's described as being so disfigured that
it actually makes Tom sick to his stomach. When the movie came out
Hera Hilmar portrayed her and the only scar was a lightning
strike-esque one that ran from under her left eye down to her chin.
How ever will Tom look past her hideous scar and fall for... oh...
wait.. it's not that bad really.
I
know this was a problem on Hollywood's part and not my interpretation
of the book, but I DID imagine her differently while reading. It was
actually a problem a lot of people had with Hester in the movie.
Nothing against Hera Hilmar, it wasn't her fault. But here's the
quote from the book: “A terrible scar ran down her face from
forehead to jaw, making it look like a portrait that had been
fruiously crossed out. Her mouth was wrenched sideways in a permanent
sneer, her nose was a smashed stump, and her single eye stared at him
out of the wreckage.” Think of that description, then look at
Hester in the book.
2. A character name that you’ve been pronouncing wrong.
Funny
you should ask. The same day Anne gave me this book tag, I found out
I was saying Amberle Elessedil wrong. I had also talked about this in
my Hufflepuff Book Tag, but I was pronouncing it "Amber El" but according to the show it's pronounced "Amber Lee." Amberle is from The Elfstones of Shannara by Terry Brooks.
3. An overused trope that is your guilty pleasure.
I love the Unlikely/Reluctant Hero. As I've mentioned so many times before, I love The Dresden Files and Harry Dresden is anything but the likely hero. A recent series I love is The Sixth World series by Rebecca Roanhorse and Maggie Hoskie is a badass god fighting hero who started out as just a regular monster hunter.
I love the thought that these heroes who save the day and world so many times were just regular people who were put into situations where they had to make the right choice.
4. A cliché character type that you like better on screen than reading about.
The painfully awkward nerd. I suffer from awful secondhand embarrassment and that goes for books AND movies. Books can get into the head of these characters and each decision they make. If they do something embarrassing I feel that I live it slower in a book vs a couple minute movie scene.
5. A word/phrase that you learnt because of its use in a book.
Racist Dog WhistleThanks to the book Yes No Maybe So by Becky Albertalli and Aisha Saeed, I learned this term that refers to a low key racists sign that meant to fly under the radar for the majority of people but be a secret sign to those in the know. So basically, a tool for garbage human beings.
6. Have you ever not read or completed a required reading book for school?
Hell
yeah I have. One time a friend paid me to write a book report for him
and he gave me a copy of the book. I didn't read the whole thing.
Instead I'd open up to random parts and read a little then find a
quote for the paper. He got an A. Two years later I ended up taking
the same class and just rewrote the paper using the same ideas in
different words and got another A. I never read the full book. I'd share the name or picture of the book, but it's been so long that I can't remember the book.
7. Have you ever (or wanted to) skipped a chapter from the point of view of a character that you weren’t interested in?
If you find a fan of fantasy books there's a really good chance that they've read and/or are a big fan of The Kingkiller Chronicles by Patrick Rothfus. I did like the books but not nearly as much as other people. The problem with Rothfus is that he's too long winded. So many parts of the book dragged on longer than they had to so they became boring. So many times I just wanted to skip to the end of a chapter because I was so bored but I knew that there'd be a chance I'd miss something important.
8. Have you ever cancelled social plans to read a book?
Not that I can think of, but I know Anne and I have changed our personal plans because we wanted to read instead, But we didn't cancel plans with friends. We just decided not to go to a movie, or go out to eat, or something in favor of staying in and reading.7. Have you ever (or wanted to) skipped a chapter from the point of view of a character that you weren’t interested in?
If you find a fan of fantasy books there's a really good chance that they've read and/or are a big fan of The Kingkiller Chronicles by Patrick Rothfus. I did like the books but not nearly as much as other people. The problem with Rothfus is that he's too long winded. So many parts of the book dragged on longer than they had to so they became boring. So many times I just wanted to skip to the end of a chapter because I was so bored but I knew that there'd be a chance I'd miss something important.
8. Have you ever cancelled social plans to read a book?
So there's my answers to the I Messed Up Book Tag. What are yours? If you did this or plan on doing it, let me know!
Yes No Maybe So | Book Review
Wednesday, 1 July 2020
May was Asian American and Pacific Islander Heritage Month and my wife and I took part in an Asian readathon. Though this was the year we were going to read more of what we wanted and not have our TBR list controlled by something like the Pop Sugar Reading Challenge (which is an awesome challenge btw), we still find readathons fun. Especially an Asian one. I myself am half Japanese and grew up very connected to my Asian half. So this readathon spoke to me.
I also wanted to expand my Asian reading horizon to include more than Japanese, Chinese, and Korean. The murder of George Floyd has made me want to expand my horizons in the African American direction, but back in early may, my focus was on Asians.
Anne was the one who made me aware of Yes No Maybe So and recommended it to me because one of the two authors is Becky Albertalli, the author of one of my favorite books Simon vs. The Homo Sapiens Agenda and the second author is Aisha Saeed, a Pakistani American and guess where Pakistan is? In South Asia! So yay! I found my first book for the readathon. What did I think of it? Here's my review.
I like YA romance. It's cute and can cover some important topics all the while having a sweet romance story. Books like the aforementioned Simon vs. The Homo Sapiens Agenda, What If It's Us?, and They Both Die At The End. What If It's Us? was written by Becky Albertalli and Adam Silvera so I knew what I was getting into with this book and knew that I'd more than likely enjoy it.
This book is about two people. Jamie Goldberg and Maya Rehman. Two teenagers who where childhood friends and who will be placed together again when they find themselves volunteering for a local political campaign that turns out to be more important to them than they could ever imagine.
Maya and Jamie have their own problems but maybe they can find answers where they least expect it, in each other.
Just like with What If It's Us?, Yes No Maybe So had two main characters and each author took one of the characters. Becky Albertalli wrote Jamie's parts while Aisha Saeed wrote Maya's parts. If you've ever read a book by Albertalli you'll recognize her style with Jamie immediately. Since I was new to Saeed's work, I didn't know what to expect from Maya's parts, but they flowed quite well and had a unique voice.
I enjoyed this book and found Maya and Jamie's friendship and romance to be cute and just what I needed after being in a reading slump. It was an easy read/listen which was just what I needed. It took a while getting used to the romance as I've only ever read gay romance from Albertalli, so when Jamie and Maya started getting chummy, I was a tad confused. That's not really a critique. Just something that made me smile.
Politics played a large part in this story and it was done well. Jamie and Maya volunteer for the campaign of a state senator hopeful. The campaign is running an uphill battle as it's for a democrat in traditionally red Georgia. I was happy to see that the book didn't take the "all republicans are evil" route as there were a few good characters who weren't democrats. It shows that the other side isn't evil, something that's important to keep in mind.
This book was aimed at a young adult audience and that was easy to see when the various problems the characters experiences showed up. Remember when you were a kid and certain problems seemed like the biggest thing ever and that your life would never be the same, but now, years later, as an adult, you can hardly even remember why it was such a big deal? Or, you remember it perfectly but are embarrassed by how seriously you took it all? This book had a mix of those types of problems and bigger, more serious problems. So even though it was a YA book, as an adult, I could relate to the problems in different ways. Either remembering what it was like to be a kid or I could see it was a bigger more widespread problem like racism.
The one thing that actually bugged me about the book was the referencing of the white supremacist OK symbol and Pepe meme. In the book they talk about how white supremacists took over the "fifi meme" and the OK symbol. I have trouble with this because it annoys me in real life. If we let these asshats take away something as basic and universal as the OK symbol, they that gives them the power to do it to so many other things. But seeing as how that was my biggest problem with the book, one could say I liked it quite a bit.
I would recommend this book to anyone who's a fan of YA romance or is just in the mood for a sweet and quick read. The audio book had two great narrators for Jamie and Maya but even if I had physically read the book, I'd have enjoyed it just as much.
Yes No Maybe So by Becky Albertalli and Aisha Saeed gets an 8 out of 11
I also wanted to expand my Asian reading horizon to include more than Japanese, Chinese, and Korean. The murder of George Floyd has made me want to expand my horizons in the African American direction, but back in early may, my focus was on Asians.
Anne was the one who made me aware of Yes No Maybe So and recommended it to me because one of the two authors is Becky Albertalli, the author of one of my favorite books Simon vs. The Homo Sapiens Agenda and the second author is Aisha Saeed, a Pakistani American and guess where Pakistan is? In South Asia! So yay! I found my first book for the readathon. What did I think of it? Here's my review.
I like YA romance. It's cute and can cover some important topics all the while having a sweet romance story. Books like the aforementioned Simon vs. The Homo Sapiens Agenda, What If It's Us?, and They Both Die At The End. What If It's Us? was written by Becky Albertalli and Adam Silvera so I knew what I was getting into with this book and knew that I'd more than likely enjoy it.
This book is about two people. Jamie Goldberg and Maya Rehman. Two teenagers who where childhood friends and who will be placed together again when they find themselves volunteering for a local political campaign that turns out to be more important to them than they could ever imagine.
Maya and Jamie have their own problems but maybe they can find answers where they least expect it, in each other.
Just like with What If It's Us?, Yes No Maybe So had two main characters and each author took one of the characters. Becky Albertalli wrote Jamie's parts while Aisha Saeed wrote Maya's parts. If you've ever read a book by Albertalli you'll recognize her style with Jamie immediately. Since I was new to Saeed's work, I didn't know what to expect from Maya's parts, but they flowed quite well and had a unique voice.
I enjoyed this book and found Maya and Jamie's friendship and romance to be cute and just what I needed after being in a reading slump. It was an easy read/listen which was just what I needed. It took a while getting used to the romance as I've only ever read gay romance from Albertalli, so when Jamie and Maya started getting chummy, I was a tad confused. That's not really a critique. Just something that made me smile.
Politics played a large part in this story and it was done well. Jamie and Maya volunteer for the campaign of a state senator hopeful. The campaign is running an uphill battle as it's for a democrat in traditionally red Georgia. I was happy to see that the book didn't take the "all republicans are evil" route as there were a few good characters who weren't democrats. It shows that the other side isn't evil, something that's important to keep in mind.
This book was aimed at a young adult audience and that was easy to see when the various problems the characters experiences showed up. Remember when you were a kid and certain problems seemed like the biggest thing ever and that your life would never be the same, but now, years later, as an adult, you can hardly even remember why it was such a big deal? Or, you remember it perfectly but are embarrassed by how seriously you took it all? This book had a mix of those types of problems and bigger, more serious problems. So even though it was a YA book, as an adult, I could relate to the problems in different ways. Either remembering what it was like to be a kid or I could see it was a bigger more widespread problem like racism.
The one thing that actually bugged me about the book was the referencing of the white supremacist OK symbol and Pepe meme. In the book they talk about how white supremacists took over the "fifi meme" and the OK symbol. I have trouble with this because it annoys me in real life. If we let these asshats take away something as basic and universal as the OK symbol, they that gives them the power to do it to so many other things. But seeing as how that was my biggest problem with the book, one could say I liked it quite a bit.
I would recommend this book to anyone who's a fan of YA romance or is just in the mood for a sweet and quick read. The audio book had two great narrators for Jamie and Maya but even if I had physically read the book, I'd have enjoyed it just as much.
Yes No Maybe So by Becky Albertalli and Aisha Saeed gets an 8 out of 11
Mid Year Freak Out Tag 2020
Sunday, 28 June 2020
Well, my friends and fellow readers. It's that time again. It's time for the Mid Year Freak Out Tag. It's my second time doing this tag but first time since I started this blog, so yay! 2020 has been a hell of a year, but thankfully books have been here to help ease the pain. My wife and I changed question 8, but I did make a note of what the original question was just in case you wanted to do it.
If you too have done the Mid Year Freak Out Tag, be sure to let me know!
Warning: Question 10 has spoiler for Frostbite by Richelle Mead. True, the book is twelve years old and I don't usually do spoiler warnings for things that are that old, but I figured I'd be nice this time.
1. Best book you’ve read so far in
2020.
There's been a book that I know I'd
love that I had been putting off for a while. I had been putting it
off more in an effort to further expand my reading horizons. But this
year I figured I should treat myself more. Last year I had ventured
out of my comfort zone more than ever before so this year I aim to
allow myself more of my old familiar genres of Sci-Fi and Fantasy.
Skyward is the best book I've
read so far this year. It was given to me two years ago by my
mother-in-law and it's just sat on my shelf. I finally read it and it
was everything I ever wanted. Brandon Sanderson is an amazing writer
who created a wonderfully immersive world and made fantastic
characters that I just loved.
2. Best sequel you've read so far in
2020.
I've
only read six sequels this year. While that does seem like a lot to
choose from, five of them are sequels in The Dresden Files
series (I'm doing a reread in preparation for the new book). For
years I've said that it's my favorite series and I still do love it a
lot, but now, rereading it for the first time in years, I now notice
the problems other people have noticed, like the oversexualization of
women. This was never a horrible issue, no reason for Jim Butcher to
be canceled, and it does get better with each installment, but I did
read a different sequel that didn't have elements I had to look past.
That
book was Frostbite by
Richelle Mead. The second book in the Vampire Diaries series. Anne
made me start this series and I wasn't sure what to expect, but I'm
so glad she made me start it. I liked the first book but the second
book was so much better. Better characters, better story, and good
character development from the first installment.
3. New release you haven't read yet,
but want to.
One day, a few years ago, I was on the
Audible app looking at what the deal of the day was and I saw it was
a LitRPG book called The Land: Founding
by Aleron Kong. I had heard of the LitRPG genre before and Aleron
Kong is called, by some, the father of LitRPG, so I figured why not
start with this?
I'm so
thankful I got that deal of the day because it gave me one of my
favorite series of all time. The eighth book in the series The
Land: Monsters came out this
year and I haven't been able to pick it up yet because of my Dresden
reread. But the minute I'm done with the Dresden
books, I'm picking The Land: Monsters
up.
4. Most anticipated release for the
second half of the year.
The
last Dresden Files
book came out in 2016 and it's been four years without anything. Jim
Butcher had an upheaval in his life and now that things are more
normal he has not one, but two Dresden books coming out. I'm finally
getting books sixteen and seventeen and I can't wait. Peace Talks is coming out on my birthday, July 14th, and Battlegrounds is coming out on September 29th.
But I
also want to acknowledge a new(ish) author who is starting a new
series and I'm very excited. Rebecca Roanhorse is the author of the
Sixth World series
which features the books Trail of Lightning and
Storm of Locusts. I
know nothing about her new series, but her other two books are five
star reads. The new book is called Black Sun and I can't wait. I've only read two
of her four books, but I already know she's a great writer.
Another book that I just found that is coming out next week is a non-fiction book about the Ghostbusters movies called Ghostbusters: The Inside Story.
5. Biggest disappointment.
Easy. The Imaginary Corpse by
Tyler Hayes. This book
should have been right up my alley. Tippy, a former imaginary friend,
is now a detective in the world of imagination. He's a yellow
triceratops in a trench coat. That's bad ass, right? I was so certain
I was going to like it that I chose it as my first new book of the
year, a new tradition my wife and I have started. But it fell so
short that it couldn't even ride a roller coaster at the state fair.
This book had so much promise. It even
had the bonus of tackling LGBT issues in Tippy's back story but it
came across as tryhard and disingenuous.
Also, Tyler Hayes has no subtlety. So
little subtlety that Hayes doesn't foreshadow coming events, he
fiveshadows it. Tippy is also an idiot of a main character and is
probably a worse detective than I've ever read before. If diamonds
are a girls best friend, then exposition is Hayes's best friend
because this book is just exposition with a big helping of tryhard.
6. Biggest surprise.
This depends on what kind of surprise.
A shocking moment in a book? Liking a book I didn't think I would?
If we're talking about liking a book I
didn't think I would, let's talk about Epitaph of a Peach by
David Mas Masumoto. It's literally a non-fiction book about this
peach farmer who wants to keep his favorite variety of peaches, but
the market has moved on to newer varieties of peaches that were made
to look a certain way that's more appealing to consumers. So he gives
his peaches one last year to decide if he should keep them. I liked
the book and I still can't exactly tell you why.
7. Favorite new author. (Debut or
new to you)
I've had two books by Catherynne M.
Valente for a while and decided to pick up The Refrigerator
Monologues and I enjoyed it a lot. I've been sitting on Space
Opera for a while but after
enjoying the other book a lot, I'm looking forward to picking up her
next book.
Another notable new (to me) author is
Richelle Mead who wrote the Vampire Academy series.
I know this is a series from way back in 2007, but my wife convinced
me to pick it up and I'm enjoying it quite a bit. I've also just
finished the second book and it was quite good.
Spensa and Jorgen from Skyward
by Brandon Sanderson. I would have thought that I'd have shipped
Spensa and Rodge, but her relationship with Jorgen was so much
better.
Also, Michelle and
Barack Obama. I know, they're real people so it doesn't count, but
hearing the story of how they met was just so sweet and I rooted for
them as a couple even though I knew how it turned out.
* The original 8th question
was newest fictional crush, but Anne and I don't actually have
fictional crushes so we changed the question.
9. Newest favorite character.
Mac from Paper Girls
by Brian K Vaughan. Thanks to my friend Fig, I discovered this short
comic series and loved it. The four main girls are great characters
but Mac is the most memorable. She's a crass, cigarette smoking bitch
who is loyal to her friends and gets shit done.
Spensa
from Skyward is
another great character. Great female character who takes no shit,
just like Mac.
10. Book that
made you cry.
Like I
mentioned above, I just finished Frostbite
the second book in the Vampire Academy series
by Richelle Mead. The ending of the climatic final battle in the book
made me cry. So allow me to warn you about a spoiler. I shouldn't
have to since this book is from 2008, but I'll do it anyway.
Spoiler Warning:
When Mason died,
that alone didn't make me cry, but when Rose covered his body trying
to protect him, I lost it.
End Spoiler
11. Book that made you happy.
I have two answers for this question.
The first book that made me happy was Becoming
by Michelle Obama. It made me happy because it reminded me of a
better time. It reminded me of a time where I could hear that the
president made a speech or tweeted and my initial reaction isn't to
cringe because it could be bad.
The
second book that made me happy is Skyward
by Brandon Sanderson but since I'm not allowing myself to use the
same answer too much, I'll instead say Night Circus
by Erin Morgenstern. It was a wonderfully written book, beautiful in
fact. The story was engrossing and it captivated me from the first
page. It was yet another book suggested by my wife and she knew I'd
love it, and she was right. I enjoyed it from the very first moment.
12. Most beautiful book you've
bought so far this year (or received)
I haven't actually purchased many books this year thanks to the new hot band Covid and the 19, but I'm lucky that there was a pretty cover in the few that I did get. I've heard mixed reviews of Foudryside by Robert Jackson Bennett.
13. What books do you need to read
by the end of the year?
How much time do you have? I have so
many books I want to read by the end, but there are a few that I know
I HAVE to read because I told myself I would back in January. Anne
and I had made a list we called 20 in 20. 20 books we had to read in
the year 2020. We also have a pile of 12 nonfiction books we have to
read this year. So far I've done... not well. Here are the books that
are left:
Binti
by Nnedi Okorafor
The Lost Symbol
by Dan Brown
The Eye of the World by
Robert Jordan
Elantris
by Brandon Sanderson
The Selection
by Kiera Cass
Space Opera
by Catherynne M Valente
The Tommyknockers by
Stephen King
Dragonflight by
Anne McCaffrey
Final Girls
by Riley Sager
Caliban's War
by James S. A. Corey
The Underground Railroad by Colson Whitehead
Leviathan by
Scott Westerfeld
Fledgling by
Octavia E. Butler
The Rise and Fall of the Dinosaurs
by Steve Brusatte
In Cold Blood
by Truman Capote
Washington's Spies
by Alexander Rose
Born Standing Up by
Steve Martin
The Monk of Mokha
by Dave Eggers
Redemption at Hacksaw Ridge
by Booton Herndon
Last
year my focus was on reading more female authors than I had before. I
did it and have kept my expanding horizons movie forward. This year I
want to read more authors of color with a focus on Black authors. But
besides Binti, The Underground Railroad, and Fledgling, I
want to keep myself open for more mood reading. If you're anything
like me, mood reading is the best way to avoid getting into a reading
slump.
The Hufflepuff Book Tag
Wednesday, 13 May 2020
My wonderful wife found this book tag and suggested we do it. In true us fashion, she completed and posted it way before I did. So here I am lollygagging behind. She found this from a YouTube channel called Abigail's Book Corner. Don't forget to also read Rooting Branches Hufflepuff Book Tag and while you're there, check out her other blogs as well.
Harry Potter: Which Harry Potter book is your favorite?
My favorite Harry Potter book is book
3, Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban. I think that not only is
it a good book, but it the best of the books that can stand on their
own.
J.K. Rowling may be slowly turning into a human dumpster fire as time goes on, but we can always escape to the original books, which in most cases, pass the test of time... that is if you ignore how she treats fat characters and the fact that Harry and Ron suck as main characters. But if you ignore that, they're still great books, especially the third one.
Loyalty: Hufflepuffs are known for their undying loyalty. Name an insta-buy author.
I don't buy a lot of brand new books anymore. But I know when Rebecca Roanhorse's next book comes out, I'll buy it and gobble it up faster than my cats eat their treats. Or a dog with bacon, that's another good analogy. I found her through Audible. Each day Audible has a different book on sale for a couple bucks and that's how I found her first book Trail of Lightning. I listened to it and fell in love right away. When the second book, Storm of Locusts, came out, I bought it right away. I'm eagerly anticipating the third book in the series so when it's available for preorder, I'll jump in it faster than lightning would strike.
Update: I learned that Rebecca Roanhorse's new book is coming out in October and isn't part of The Sixth World series that I love so much. But, none the less, I have preordered it.
Animals/Magical Creatures: As Hufflepuffs, we tend to have a great love for animals. Name a book/series that has your favorite animal/magical creature in it.
In The Traveling Cat Chronicles, Hiro Arikawa does a great job writing from the cat Nana's point of view and making it totally believable that a cat would think things like that. She wrote from the perspective of a cat without it being cringey or tryhard which isn't always an easy thing to do. Nana had a unique personality without being a caricature.
Trustworthy: We Hufflepuffs are very trustworthy, however books can also be very trustworthy. Name a series in which none of the books disappointed you.
I try not to use an answer more than twice in these tags, but I just have to with this one. If you've ever read a book tag blog by me then you may know my answer to this. The Dresden Files by Jim Butcher is the most reliable book series I have ever read.
I liked the first book and it sucked me into a now fifteen book series with two short story collections. Later, in this very blog, I'll b honest about some of the problems with the earlier books in the series, but each book that comes out is the best one in the series. Which means that so far, Skin Game (the 15th book) is the best while Storm Front (The 1st) is the worst (or least best).
Caring: Us Hufflepuffs care for others a lot, even fictional characters. Name a book/series whose main character holds a special place in your heart.
I almost don't want to reread the Shannara series since it holds such a special place in my heart and Amberle Elessdil is, and hopefully will stay, one of my favorite characters of all time. I'm also terrified of watching the show and learning that I've been saying the name wrong this whole time.
Update: I now know that I'm pronouncing the name wrong. It's pronounced "Amber Lee" where I was saying "Amber El."
Update: I now know that I'm pronouncing the name wrong. It's pronounced "Amber Lee" where I was saying "Amber El."
Kindness: Hufflepuffs always strive to be kind to others, no matter who they are. Name a book/series that you love despite its flaws and imperfections.
I love this series but it's not perfect. But now that I'm more aware of gender and other social issues that I once was, I can also appreciate that this series does have good female characters, even if Jim Butcher includes body descriptions as part of their introduction. Also, Dresden thankfully avoids the Women in Refrigerators trope (bad things happening to women as a way to move a male's story forward).
Patience: Hufflepuffs tend to be very patient, and that's a useful trait when reading slow paced books. Name a book you struggled to get through, but stuck it out until the end.
If you had asked me a few years ago, I would have put Brent Week's Lightbringer series at the top of my loved series list. But the second to last book in the series Blood Mirror was so painfully slow that I had to force myself to read it. My friends who have read the final book in the series swear that The Burning White is better than Blood Mirror, but they also didn't have the same issues I did with the book. So we'll see when I finish the series, but Blood Mirror was so hard to read that it killed the series for me.
So if you're a Hufflepuff, consider doing this book tag too and letting me know what your answers are. Are you a different house? That's okay, I won't judge you. You can find your own book tag and then let me know! Maybe we can find new books to love.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)









































